You won't have to spend a lot to get a great toaster. Look for one whose controls are easy to use, and consider that toasters with plastic housing are less likely to retain heat, so they won't feel as hot to the touch as metal models.
If you want perfectly browned bread, opt for the straightforwardness of a basic toaster. But if you prefer a multifunction appliance that can not only toast but also bake muffins and heat frozen snacks, a toaster oven could be right for your needs.